As a result in the past 15+ years of gaming I’ve owned 2 fighting games: BlazBlue and Soul Calibur 2 (and arguably the Super Smash Bros series). Compared the paltry number of fighting games I own, I have an extensive RPG collection, including games like the Witcher. The Witcher is a grubby, unpolished game but as an RPG fan I ultimately enjoyed it very much, completing 3 playthroughs of it. While issues like inconsistent voice acting, a mediocre fighting system and being graphically poor, it was a game I felt had a lot of heart/soul. Additionally the game was pretty well written, with an interesting world and characters, had some good moral quantries, great music and locations. The game also had a good difficulty curve in that enemies always felt like a threat. Another plus was that the economy system worked well, gold always had value throughout all stages of the game.
EDIT: Switching back to 'out of 10' because I find 'out of 5' too hard to quantify fully.